WYOMING – The Texas Public Policy Foundation (TPPF) is challenging the United States Forest Service over its longstanding enforcement of federal restrictions that prohibit individuals from filming videos in designated wilderness areas if the footage is later monetized or used to promote a business.

The lawsuit, brought on behalf of Wyoming resident Joshua Smunk and the BlueRibbon Coalition, stems from a September 2025 elk hunting trip in Wyoming’s Shoshone National Forest. During the trip, Smunk appeared in a video featuring pack llamas from his outdoor recreation business. Although Smunk neither published nor monetized the video, Forest Service officials subsequently accused him of violating the Wilderness Act of 1964 because his llamas appeared in the footage and the video was monetized on YouTube.

In subsequent communications, Forest Service officials warned Smunk that videos filmed in wilderness areas could not be monetized, even after filming had concluded. Officials also indicated that the agency monitors social media for potential violations and pursues enforcement against individuals who publish such content.

TPPF argues that the Forest Service has exceeded its statutory authority by attempting to regulate speech and activities occurring outside federal wilderness areas. The lawsuit further contends that the government’s interpretation of the Wilderness Act violates the First Amendment by restricting constitutionally protected expression based on whether a video generates revenue or references a commercial enterprise.

Read more about Smunk v. Coffin.

###